What sauce do you use for pickle pizza?

The most popular sauce for pickle pizza is garlic ranch , known for its creamy texture and savory, herby punch. It perfectly complements the tangy, salty nature of dill pickles. Other excellent alternatives include creamy Alfredo , sour cream–based white sauces , or homemade garlic dill sauces . Tomato sauce is usually avoided because it clashes with the pickle’s acidity.

Is pickle pizza a Midwest thing?

Yes, pickle pizza originated and gained popularity in the Midwest , especially in states like Minnesota and Iowa. It was first served at local fairs and small pizza shops, where bold flavors are welcomed. Though it started in the Midwest, its popularity has since gone national , with foodies across the U.S. embracing this trend.

When did Funky Pickle Pizza close?

Funky Pickle Pizza , known for pioneering adventurous topping combinations including pickles, closed in early 2021 . The closure was largely due to challenges during the COVID-19 pandemic. Despite this, its unique menu left a lasting impression and helped spark the broader trend of briny, bold-flavored pizzas .

Does Papa John's have pickle pizza?

Papa John’s tested a dill pickle pizza in select U.S. markets in 2023 , which featured garlic dill sauce, sliced pickles, mozzarella, cheddar, and a ranch drizzle. It hasn’t become a permanent menu item, but the company hinted at a possible return depending on demand. Fans are hopeful it’ll make a national comeback in 2025.

Pickle Pie Pizza: The Best Viral Recipe You’ve Never Tried (2025)

Ingredients

Pizza dough
Dill pickles
Garlic ranch sauce
Mozzarella cheese
Optional: cheddar,onions, jalapeños

Cook Mode Prevent your screen from going dark

Instructions

Preheat oven to 475°F
Roll out dough, spread sauce
Add cheese, pickles, and toppings
Bake 10–12 minutes
Cool slightly and serve with fresh dill

Prep Time: 15 minutes
Cook Time: 12 minutes